New Ideas Hub
New Ideas Hub · Essays

What receives our attention

The books we will not read

A bedside pile, a friend's selection, and an imaginary library reveal what remains unsettled in the books we keep for later.

A table crowded with a globe, open books, a violin and loose papers under a heavy curtain.
Edwaert Collier, Vanitas Still Life, 1662 · The Met, public domain

The books beside a bed are close enough to reach without getting up. Their spines make a short row, or disappear into a pile when the surface begins to fill. Oliver Burkeman places bedside books in the same predicament as a podcast queue or the articles saved in Instapaper. Each is a place where something that seemed worth returning to can quietly acquire the weight of an unfinished task.

There is a peculiar intimacy in this arrangement. A book has been admitted to the part of the house where we are least prepared to impress anyone, yet it can still make us feel underqualified. Its title is visible while its contents remain largely unknown. We know enough to suspect that it has something for us, which can be a more persistent feeling than knowing exactly what that something is.

A particular pile may be perfectly possible to finish. Six books are six books, and even a neglected stack has a last page somewhere inside it. There is no reason to make an ordinary shortage of evenings into an absolute law. The difficulty changes when the pile stands for everything we might yet discover, including the books whose existence we will learn about halfway through the first one.

Then finishing becomes a strangely mobile prospect. A sentence in one book opens a door into another; a conversation makes an unfamiliar subject suddenly necessary. Even a season of devoted reading can leave us with a larger sense of what we have missed. The reader who completes the original stack may have become a person for whom a different stack now matters.

That is one reason the unread book can be hard to put away. It belongs partly to an imagined continuation of ourselves. The person who will understand this difficult novel, or finally have a language for that obscure interest, is waiting somewhere beyond its cover. Closing a cupboard on the book can feel like being inhospitable to someone who has traveled a long way to meet us.

But the imagined reader is unusually well provided for. There are no interruptions in that person’s evening, no paragraph that must be read again because its first half has disappeared from memory. The future seems to possess a kind of attention the present is always borrowing against. A book set aside for that future receives excellent theoretical conditions and no actual reader.

In On Reading and Books, Schopenhauer distinguishes buying a volume from acquiring its contents or the time to read it. He also values reflection and rereading. The purchased object can be possessed at once. What reading makes available to the mind requires something slower.

There is an awkwardness here for anyone hoping that a cleared shelf will settle the matter. A reread book adds nothing to the number of titles completed for the first time. The visible evidence of progress is almost disappointingly small. Yet a familiar page can become difficult in a new place, because the reader has finally lived through something the page was already describing.

Schopenhauer’s confidence in choosing good books over bad ones leaves a further discomfort. What happens when the books still waiting are good? A choice can be perfectly defensible and still involve a loss. The unwritten life of the other choice remains available to the imagination, which rarely bothers to include its dull passages.

This makes the language of waste feel a little crude. An hour spent with one worthwhile book excludes another worthwhile hour; its value does not erase that exclusion. Reading acquires some of the sadness of an ordinary afternoon, which can be spent in only one way even when several ways would have been lovely. The sadness need not be evidence that the afternoon went wrong.

A letter from Joseph Joubert to Madame de Beaumont offers a smaller scale. He imagines gathering books suited to reviving her interest and having them close by her bed. The selection is addressed to a particular friend. Its smallness belongs to the care with which someone is being considered, rather than to a wish that she should know less.

A book selected in friendship arrives with an extra kind of attention inside it. Someone has pictured another person’s mind making room for these pages. There may be an error in that picture, as there can be in any gift. Still, the selection has a human outline: this book, for this person, rather than the much colder possibility of everything worth knowing, for everyone.

The bedside changes slightly in that light. A small group of books can suggest companionship without claiming to represent a complete education. There is room for curiosity to exceed the selection without turning the selection into a failure. A friend does not become less interesting because there are other people we will never meet.

Thomas Browne’s Musæum Clausum presents an imagined collection of books, pictures, and rarities, mixing inventions with references to genuine lost works. After describing its treasures, the narrator cannot say where they are. This is a different kind of unread library. Its pages cannot simply be taken down from a shelf when the reader finds a free evening.

The distinction matters because an unavailable book can retain a peculiar perfection. It is easy to feel a pure longing for a work that cannot disappoint us with an actual first chapter. A book within reach has a less protected existence. It must compete with fatigue, and it may turn out to require a kind of patience we do not presently have.

Browne’s imaginary shelves and an ordinary bedside pile therefore hold different kinds of distance. One withholds the possibility of an encounter; the other leaves that possibility open, sometimes for years. An available book we never read has not been lost to the world. The loss, if that is the word, is confined to the life in which the encounter never happened.

That smaller loss can still be real. There are things we might have recognized sooner, pleasures we might have known, sentences that might have accompanied a difficult stretch. We cannot itemize these absences, because reading the books would be necessary to find out what they were. The unread volume leaves us with the outline of a possibility and very little knowledge of its size.

Meanwhile, the book being read has lost that convenient vagueness. It has a particular voice and a particular pace, and perhaps a disappointing middle. Attention discovers these limits as surely as it discovers beauty. Somewhere among the pages, the promise of any experience at all becomes this experience, occupying part of a life that cannot be spent twice.

Beside the bed, the remaining books keep their place. Some may eventually move to another room or another reader; some may wait until their subjects no longer feel urgent. Their presence need not be either an accusation or a source of wisdom. They are books we wanted, near the book for which, tonight, there was time.

The others are still good books.

Further reading