New Ideas Hub
New Ideas Hub · Essays

The time before

The day after the fresh start

A notebook, Montaigne’s amended pages, and Seneca’s admissions complicate the hope that a new beginning will arrive with a different self.

A park seen from a high window on a spring morning, paths and lawns opening toward the city.
Camille Pissarro, The Garden of the Tuileries on a Spring Morning, 1899 · The Met, public domain

A fancy notebook waits for a schedule while files clutter a computer desktop. In Oliver Burkeman’s account of finishing his book edits, an overflowing inbox completes this unpromising arrangement. He describes the temptation to reorganize it all. The work already under way has acquired a rival: the prospect of arranging a life in which the work might finally go more smoothly.

The notebook is a sympathetic object here. Its order can exist before the days it describes have happened, before an interruption has arrived with a perfectly legitimate claim. A schedule has room for the work without yet having to accommodate the person doing it. On paper, even Tuesday can look as though it has turned over a new leaf.

Burkeman makes a distinction between changing a life and escaping its history. The person who undertakes the change is already a consequence of that history, including the parts they would prefer to leave behind. An improved arrangement remains available; an entirely unencumbered arranger is harder to produce. There is something almost comic about the hope that yesterday’s self will do all the packing and then agree to stay behind.

The day after a fresh start brings this difficulty down to the scale of a desk. The files may be easier to find, yet the question of what to write remains. A new routine can give an old difficulty a better appointment time. This is a genuine change, though a modest one beside the imagined arrival of a person who would no longer find the difficulty difficult.

The calendar has some evidence in its favor. In three archival studies, Hengchen Dai, Katherine Milkman, and Jason Riis found temporal landmarks associated with increased diet-related searches, university gym visits, and goal commitments. These were observational findings, not proof that a date causes everyone to change. Starting activity did not establish lasting success, and the researchers noted that holiday-related spikes could fade quickly. A beginning can matter without guaranteeing the life that follows it.

That leaves a smaller disappointment than the discovery that beginnings are useless. A Monday might help someone begin, while still containing much of the previous Friday. The sadness enters when the old difficulty feels like evidence that the beginning was counterfeit. Something has happened, but it has failed to happen on the scale of a conversion.

Montaigne begins his essay on repentance with a person already made. He allows that he might have fashioned himself differently if the making were still available to him in that way. Instead, the person at hand becomes the subject of the account. There is no preliminary interval in which he first becomes suitable for examination. His existing life supplies the material, including whatever makes him an awkward subject.

Yet this person is also changing from minute to minute. His phrase “I do not paint its being, I paint its passage” makes room for a portrait whose subject will not stay still. The account belongs to an hour, rather than fixing its subject forever. This makes an interesting companion for a schedule: one page anticipates the person who will arrive, while the other admits how quickly its description may need to change.

The Bordeaux Copy of Montaigne’s essays gives that thought a physical counterpart. It is a printed 1588 edition bearing his handwritten additions and deletions. The printed book had become a place for further thought.

Still, a printed page with writing added to it offers a different image of change from the untouched notebook. The earlier words remain part of what the later words have to work with. There may be correction, qualification, or a thought that could not have occurred before the first version existed. Even disagreement has an address. Something had to be there for the next thought to find it.

Elsewhere in the same essay, Montaigne separates imagining a superior nature from possessing its capacities. His arm gains no strength from his ability to picture a stronger person. The observation catches a small embarrassment in plans for renewal: imagining the future self can feel remarkably like having done some of that self’s work. The picture is vivid enough to borrow credit from what it depicts.

Montaigne’s acceptance of an existing nature does not erase his concern with moral correction. His distinction would become too comfortable if every failure could claim permanent residence simply because it had arrived first. The difficulty lies in allowing an unfinished person to remain responsible without requiring a wholly different person to appear. An amendment can be serious even when the page beneath it is familiar.

Seneca sounds less settled than an authority on time might be expected to sound. “I cannot boast that I waste nothing” is his admission in the first letter to Lucilius. His warning about postponement comes with his own losses attached. He can account for them without claiming to have abolished them. The person speaking about wasted life is still implicated in it.

That admission changes the company at the desk. The notebook need not be placed beside an imaginary observer whose time has never leaked away. Even the philosopher has an account to give, and it contains losses. I find more room for thought in that imperfect accounting than in the prospect of a schedule without a single crossed-out intention.

In another letter, Seneca considers the hope that a change of scenery will relieve discontent. The traveler, he argues, brings himself along. Yet he also allows that surroundings can matter, a qualification easily lost when the argument is reduced to a memorable rebuke. A different room may help. It need not manufacture a different inhabitant to have been worth entering.

The reorganized desktop can have this ordinary usefulness. A file can become easier to find without turning its owner into someone who never hesitates. The notebook can hold a workable schedule without holding the outline of a redeemed character. Perhaps the day after the fresh start feels disappointing because its improvements are available only to someone so recognizably continuous with yesterday.

There is a tenderness in that continuity which the untouched page cannot quite accommodate. The person with the old difficulty is also the person who wanted things to be different. Whatever changes will belong to that person, with a history still attached. The next page may contain something unforeseen, even in handwriting that has become painfully easy to recognize.

The new life has the old handwriting.

Further reading