Three handwritten sides of an A5 notebook: this is the scale of the writing Oliver Burkeman describes in his essay on morning pages. He has no outside reader in mind. Julia Cameron describes Morning Pages as three handwritten pages with no restriction on subject. The notebook is being used, although the writing has no appointment beyond it.
That last detail can be surprisingly difficult to leave alone. A person might draw the view from a kitchen window simply to spend longer with it. The drawing may have no later use, being neither an accurate record of the view nor something wanted on the wall. Still, the afternoon has taken a shape around it, even if the paper is put away afterward.
The pencil has followed the crooked edge of a roof. Something usually passed over has occupied a little time. Perhaps the drawing is clumsy, and perhaps making it has been frustrating rather than soothing. None of this prevents the afternoon from containing an encounter that would otherwise have been absent. Whether that is enough seems a more intimate question than whether the picture is good.
Virginia Woolf gives private thought a material setting in A Room of One’s Own. Her speaking narrator is an invention, and the argument takes shape through that invented life. Money and a lock on the door stand for conditions in which contemplation and independent thought become possible. The room makes it hard to discuss imaginative freedom as though it were available merely by deciding to feel free.
A door costs something before it can be closed. So does an hour in which nobody needs what the person behind it can provide. There is an easy romance in the picture of someone quietly making things, especially when the picture leaves out the rent and the unfinished household work. The phrase for myself can sound modest while naming a substantial claim on space and time.
Woolf also resists the authority of literary rankings over what someone wishes to write. Her argument does not require an empty world in which books have no readers. It allows a writer’s attention to have a direction that has not been supplied by the judges. In that sense, private work begins earlier than the decision about whether to show anything: it begins in having some say over what deserves an afternoon.
This might include a very ordinary subject. Nothing in the roof outside the kitchen has changed while the pencil moves, but its edge is no longer quite so familiar. Its interest lies in the person looking and in the peculiar difficulty of getting that angle onto paper. A second attempt can matter without belonging to a plan for improvement. Sometimes the angle is simply still there, and still wrong.
In the fourth book of the Meditations, Marcus Aurelius considers beautiful things, among them a flower and an emerald. In George Long’s translation, he describes beauty as “not having praise as part of itself.” The remark separates a thing from the response it receives. It does not establish that every private drawing is beautiful, or that the person making it must be pleased with the result.
The separation leaves room for a less comfortable kind of satisfaction. A drawing may contain one line its maker likes and several that seem beyond repair. The liked line does not become better in company, and the awkward ones remain awkward when the room is empty. The maker can remain absorbed in this uneven collection of marks, wanting to return to it without needing to call it finished.
The Meditations themselves are generally understood by scholars as writing directed toward Marcus’s own moral improvement, rather than a systematic treatise for the public. This describes a purpose, not a guarantee that nobody else ever saw the pages. The words address someone who also made them. A written reminder gives a thought another occasion to be encountered, after the moment in which it first seemed obvious has passed.
There is something touching in that slight distance between the person writing and the person returning to read. They share a name, but they do not necessarily share a mood or an attention span. A sentence can remain on the page while its author becomes distracted. The object has a small practical advantage over the intention: it can wait without remembering to wait. A note about patience may read differently after an argument, although nothing on the page has changed since it was written down.
Long supplies another instance of private usefulness in the prefatory account of his translation. His account includes the words “I made this translation for my own use” before explaining that he subsequently decided to publish it. The statement belongs to the translator, not to Marcus. It gives the work an ordinary first destination: the person for whose use the words were being made.
Publication came later, but later need not mean more real. Long’s account locates a reason for the work before the decision to print it. Its eventual printing leaves that earlier purpose intact. A thing can change its place in a life without requiring its previous place to be explained away. Private work need not promise to stay private in order to count.
Burkeman’s account returns to the value of observing a ritual, without requiring a particular outcome from it. That is a delicate kind of usefulness to name, because an explanation can quickly become another demand. The quiet page is asked to make the rest of the day more efficient, or to produce a more impressive person. Even a defense of private work can end by assigning it extra work.
There may be afternoons when the drawing feels sufficient and afternoons when it does not. Wanting company for something made alone is hardly a failure of independence. Yet the absence of company need not leave the whole experience waiting to begin. The pencil has worn down a little; the roof has been looked at. Enough might describe the relation between that particular person and that particular afternoon, without becoming a rule for anyone else.
The drawing has already had its afternoon.
