New Ideas Hub
New Ideas Hub · Essays

What receives our attention

A day with nothing to show

A summer morning and a borrowed axe complicate the search for a respectable explanation of time that passed.

People rest and stroll on a riverbank lawn in summer, painted in small strokes of colour.
Georges Seurat, Study for "A Sunday on La Grande Jatte", 1884 · The Met, public domain

A book lies open on a reader’s lap beside a window. It could be Jenny Odell’s How to Do Nothing, a few pages read before the reader looks up. For a while, the window holds their attention. In this imagined afternoon, the next page is still waiting when they look down again.

Even here, a small demand can find its way into the room. The reader may want the book to make this use of an afternoon easier to defend. Does a day without an accomplishment need a better accomplishment hidden inside it? The wish to defend such a day can arrive almost as quickly as the wish to have one.

An afternoon can pass without leaving much that fits into an answer. There was lunch, a little time at the window, something half read. Asked what happened, a person might say nothing, with an apology already forming around the word. The afternoon itself may have felt quite different before it was asked to become a report.

The easiest defense borrows from tomorrow. The time was restorative; an idea might emerge from it; work will surely go better afterward. These are possible explanations, offered here as imagined pleas rather than promises. Their appeal is understandable, but so is their small threat: if tomorrow goes badly too, the afternoon has lost its alibi.

In the opening of the Sounds chapter of Walden, Henry David Thoreau describes sitting in reverie through a summer morning, from sunrise until noon. He allows the hours considerable room on the page without supplying them with a memorable accomplishment. The passage has the curious effect of making the missing result seem less urgent. Noon arrives without settling the matter.

Nearby is his sentence, “I love a broad margin to my life.” A margin belongs to the page while remaining outside its written business. It need not conceal a second text, waiting to prove that the apparently empty part was occupied all along. The image leaves space for something harder to praise than secret industry: a portion of life without a prepared explanation.

Yet Walden also contains the borrowed axe and the acknowledgment that Thoreau occupied land with permission. The margin had material conditions, and the experiment was no demonstration of complete self-sufficiency. Those details belong beside the summer morning, not in a footnote designed to spoil it. They change what the scene can reasonably offer another person.

A borrowed tool does not make reverie fraudulent. It does make the fantasy of an entirely independent refusal harder to sustain. There is a difference between admiring someone’s unhurried hours and treating those hours as an option available on equal terms to anyone. A window can look out on the same light while opening onto very different obligations.

Robert Louis Stevenson’s An Apology for Idlers approaches the difficulty with a defense already announced in its title. His idler is engaged in activities that prevailing standards fail to recognize. That is a useful correction to the accusation of emptiness. It also changes the charge: the day was occupied, after all, although its occupations had been assessed badly.

Stevenson gives companionship weight in his argument, suggesting that business can crowd out obligations to family and friends. Here the busy person, rather than the idler, becomes answerable for an absence. The reversal has warmth because a person may be easier to love when there is time to be with them. But the defense still brings something valuable into court and lays it on the table.

I find that generosity appealing and its terms a little troubling. A pleasant companion has something to show for an afternoon, even if nobody would call it a deliverable. Someone who spent the same hours alone, bored and not noticeably kinder afterward, would make a weaker case. A kinder judge can still require evidence from the person standing before them.

Under these terms, even leisure can acquire a demanding character. It must be attentive enough to count as attention, sociable enough to count as friendship, spacious enough to count as a meaningful refusal. An ordinary disappointing afternoon has very little chance. The argument began by loosening a standard and ended with an entrance examination for a different kind of worthiness.

Stevenson does acknowledge hunger and the workhouse as constraints on idleness, although his light treatment of them offers little comfort. A cheerful argument cannot make the threat of poverty small. The ability to leave an hour unexplained may itself depend on security. There is something cruel in turning that freedom into a measure of character, then admiring most the people best placed to possess it.

Odell’s published talk acknowledges the employment flexibility behind her garden visits and the volunteers who maintained the roses. Both details keep the garden attached to the world that sustains it. A space can be free of demands for one person because another person is tending it. The freedom remains real, but its account cannot stop at the bench.

This is where the question resists an elegant answer. An unproductive day does not cancel a promise to somebody who needed us, or make unpaid work vanish because we preferred not to notice it. Responsibility has people attached to it. Yet a demand to justify every hour can persist long after those particular claims have been met.

There may be no neglected child, no abandoned shift, no friend left waiting in the particular afternoon under examination. There may simply be an uneasy person looking for a respectable description of some time that passed. To invent hidden work for that person would be a peculiar consolation. It would save the afternoon by refusing to accept what was difficult about it.

The book title remains appealing without resolving this. There is room to question the terms on which a day is judged without claiming that every use of a day is beyond question. There is also room for an hour to have been dull, undistinguished, even regretted, without being converted into evidence against the person who lived it. Nothing remarkable need have happened at the window.

By evening, the defense has become the work.

Further reading