New Ideas Hub
New Ideas Hub · Essays

Where ideas live

The notebook and the work

A pencil timeline and two older accounts of attention complicate the difference between keeping an idea, living with it, and making something.

An open sketchbook: a faint study on the left page, a seated figure drawn in pencil on the right.
Edgar Degas, Album of Forty-five Figure Studies, ca. 1882-85 · The Met, public domain

A pencil timeline in Austin Kleon’s notebook arranges the lifetimes of composers. He made it while reading Jan Swafford’s Language of the Spirit. The book supplied something to think about; the drawing gave that thinking a shape. The modest page complicates a familiar suspicion about notebooks: that they are places where work goes to wait for us.

Kleon describes understanding the overlap of composers’ lives through drawing, and treats the drawing as a by-product of learning. Its usefulness need not depend on a later visit to the page. Something has already happened between the book and the pencil. Keeping the result and having had the experience are separate matters, even when the same notebook holds evidence of both.

An imagined notebook of our own might contain a rather different page: a title for an essay, followed by a few sentences about what it could become. On the next visit, the title still seems promising. Another thought joins the others, and the page acquires the reassuring density of a project. There is now more to keep, though it may remain difficult to say what has been made.

The pleasure in this deserves some respect. A thought that would otherwise disappear has somewhere to return to, and its return can make an ordinary afternoon feel connected to a larger interest. The notebook gives continuity to something that has no place on the calendar. Living with an idea may be valuable long before there is any reason to call it work.

Leonardo’s instructions for figure composition give preservation a more specific purpose. He prescribes a portable notebook in which to sketch people talking, laughing, quarreling, and otherwise occupied with one another. These are instructions for gathering material, rather than a record establishing his daily habits. The gestures matter because a figure eventually drawn will need to do something more particular than simply resemble a human being.

When the notebook is full, Leonardo calls for another, while the earlier sketches are retained. His reason is almost disarmingly ordinary: “the memory is incapable of retaining them”. The abundance of forms and positions exceeds what memory can hold. Here, keeping a page acknowledges that an encounter cannot be summoned back in all its particularity merely because the artist will later have a use for it.

There is generosity toward a future self in that arrangement. The person at work later will have access to something the person watching now could easily lose. Yet the retained sketch also has an independence from the occasion that produced it. It may survive the first intention for it, awaiting a drawing quite unlike the one its keeper had in mind.

Leonardo’s notebook and Kleon’s timeline therefore leave different questions behind. One preserves observed material for another occasion; the other records an understanding reached through the activity itself. Neither offers a verdict on a notebook containing the same unfinished idea for years. Its persistence could mean that the idea remains alive, or simply that paper is unusually good at keeping things unchanged.

Emerson makes this distinction harder in a useful way. In The American Scholar, he writes, “There is then creative reading as well as creative writing.” A reader’s encounter with a book can belong to invention rather than merely precede it. The sentence leaves room for work whose outward appearance is someone sitting still with pages another person has written.

That room matters to the notebook. A passage copied out may seem to have traveled only from one page to another, but the act can also place it beside an objection that did not previously have words. The resulting thought may never become an essay. It can still change the terms on which a person understands something, including the idea that seemed to require an essay in the first place.

Emerson does not leave the scholar entirely among books. He treats action as essential, though subordinate, to scholarship, connecting thought with experience. This makes a life beyond the page part of what the page may eventually mean. It also complicates the comforting picture of a notebook that can become sufficient to itself, indefinitely supplied with further reading and protected from anything that might alter the subject.

But Emerson also allows time between experience and reflection. What has only just happened may become intelligible later, when it can be regarded from a little distance. This is an awkward allowance for anyone hoping to distinguish useful waiting from delay by looking at a calendar. The absence of a finished piece tells us very little about whether thought is still taking place.

An old note can consequently meet a different reader without ever changing hands. A sentence that once seemed complete may now seem to stop before the interesting part. An example can lose its charm; a detail barely noticed before can become the reason for returning. In such a meeting, the notebook’s apparent stillness conceals a disagreement between the person who wrote and the person who has come back.

That disagreement seems closer to making than the mere addition of another page, although it offers no convenient way of measuring progress. The idea has encountered something it cannot simply absorb. Perhaps its original question has become less persuasive, or the experience it hoped to explain now looks different. Even abandoning a projected piece can involve thought that keeping the project intact would have spared.

There remains a quieter possibility: the idea has become a companion, and no longer asks to become anything else. A person may enjoy imagining a book without secretly owing the world that book. The tenderness of this arrangement does not make the imagined book a manuscript. It does make the absence of a manuscript an insufficient reason to dismiss what the idea has meant.

The notebook can hold these different relationships without labeling them for us. There may be material awaiting use, traces of thinking already done, and a project whose company has become more important than its completion. The same page can move between these conditions as the years change its reader. When it finally opens again, the unfinished work may no longer be the thing that has waited longest.

Sometimes the notebook has been keeping an earlier version of us.

Further reading