New Ideas Hub
New Ideas Hub · Essays

What receives our attention

The world at walking speed

A snowy print and an arranged garden path suggest that noticing a place may give it more independence from our wishes.

A village under deep snow at evening, a few figures walking slowly along the road.
Utagawa Hiroshige, Evening Snow at Kanbara, ca. 1833-34 · The Met, public domain

The travelers in Hiroshige’s Evening Snow at Kanbara have a stretch of white road to cross. Above them, snow rests on roofs and dark hills rise behind the houses. Their small figures give the landscape an inconvenience: somebody has to get through it. What might otherwise be admired as a view becomes a place where arrival takes time. The snow belongs to the picture, but the distance seems to belong to them.

There is a familiar way of moving through a place in which almost everything becomes evidence of how much farther remains. A storefront means the next turn. A row of trees means the bus stop is near. These things have been noticed, quite efficiently, without being allowed much existence beyond their usefulness. Even beauty can enter this arrangement as a brief improvement to the journey, something pleasant while the real business waits elsewhere.

Walking speed offers no automatic escape from that habit. A person can hurry inwardly while moving very slowly, carrying an argument across several blocks without seeing much of any of them. And neither the freedom to wander nor the physical ability to walk is evenly available. The interesting possibility lies somewhere other than mileage: a place might cease to be merely the interval between the self and its next appointment.

Hiroshige’s print, dated around 1833 or 1834, complicates the idea that such a change delivers an untouched world. The snow is imagined: Hiroshige traveled in summer, and heavy snowfall is unusual there. The weather is therefore part of the making. A scene can invite close attention without serving as a literal report of what its maker encountered.

That invention does not make the travelers’ predicament less imaginable. It may help it become imaginable, giving their passage a resistance we can almost feel. The artist has made certain things matter together. This is an uncomfortable detail for anyone hoping that attention means finally setting interpretation aside. Even the wish to see a place as it really is arrives with a notion of what a real place ought to look like.

In The Book of Tea, Kakuzō Okakura describes another passage, the garden approach to a tea room. Stepping stones, pine needles, and mossy lanterns belong to his account of an approach that prepares perception. The destination has a threshold longer than its doorway. Before the visitor arrives, the path has already begun to change the terms of arrival. The small distance is doing considerable work.

Okakura gives that work a mischievous illustration in an anecdote about the tea master Rikiu and his son Shoan. Shoan has cleaned the path carefully, yet Rikiu remains dissatisfied. Rikiu shakes a tree, scattering leaves over the ground. In Okakura’s telling, the appearance of natural ease requires one more intervention after the work seems finished. The father has found a use for what the son removed.

The leaves are particularly awkward for our wish to discover beauty lying there, untouched by anyone’s plans. Someone has decided where disorder belongs. Someone has judged a spotless path insufficient. Yet the result is not simply discredited by that knowledge. A guest can know that a garden has been composed and still encounter something there that was not included in the guest’s expectations.

The tea garden and the snowy print ask different things of their visitors. One belongs to the ritual preparation of a place; the other offers an image to be contemplated. Treating them as interchangeable lessons in slowing down would erase much of what gives each its interest. Still, both disturb the comforting picture of attention as a window that becomes perfectly transparent once the observer has stopped being busy.

Craig Mod’s November 2020 account of walking the Tōkaidō makes that disturbance contemporary. Citing Hiroshige as an inspiration, he describes posting single-shot videos of the road’s ordinary scenes. He also reports hours spent making and managing media alongside the walking. This was attention with a frame and an audience, not a technological retreat. The walk included the work of deciding what another person would be able to see.

A camera makes that decision visible, but its absence would hardly abolish selection. There would still be the thing that caught the eye, the thing passed over, the thing remembered because it fitted an unfinished thought. This need not reduce every encounter to a private projection. It does make the encounter less innocent. We bring ourselves to a place, including the preferences through which parts of it become easier to notice.

Perhaps what becomes available is the chance for those preferences to meet some resistance. An imagined ordinary street might contain a window display that seems ridiculous until one object holds our interest. A patch of shade might matter before the building that casts it does. These are small revisions, without the satisfying outline of a revelation. The world has supplied something that was missing from the account we brought along.

Nor does giving a place more existence guarantee that we will enjoy it. Its noise may become harder to ignore. A closed shop might interrupt the pleasing story we were making about the neighborhood. The people who live there have purposes that need not enrich our afternoon. Once a place stops functioning as background, it becomes less obedient to the mood in which we happened to arrive.

That loss of obedience seems worth staying with. There is a form of appreciation that quietly requires the world to be charming, as though careful looking were a reservation that ought to be honored. The unlovely detail then feels like a failure of the visit. But an encounter that permits disappointment has allowed the place a little more independence. It can be present without having pleased us.

The figures in Hiroshige’s snow remain useful company here. We can admire the white road while imagining that they would prefer to have crossed it already. Our pleasure and their implied difficulty occupy the same sheet. Neither quite cancels the other, and neither exhausts what is there. A world that has come forward from the background can hold more than the feeling we wanted from it.

The view has other things to do.

Further reading