New Ideas Hub
New Ideas Hub · Essays

Becoming a beginner

The tool that felt like permission

A watercolor box and a perspective frame open a question about the permission we seek from objects, and the help they cannot supply.

A woodcut: an artist draws a reclining woman through a gridded frame set up on the table between them.
Albrecht Dürer, Draughtsman Making a Perspective Drawing of a Reclining Woman, ca. 1600 · The Met, public domain

A watercolor box can close around an afternoon’s intentions. In a letter to his brother Theo in August 1882, Vincent van Gogh described one with a lid that served as a palette, a practical improvement on carrying loose colors on saucers. The arrangement is modest enough to escape our attention. Yet there is a difference between wanting to paint somewhere and having something that can be carried there.

That difference can acquire a meaning far beyond convenience. An activity that seemed to belong to another kind of person begins to fit inside an ordinary day. The materials have somewhere to go; the attempt has a conceivable beginning. Nothing has established that the painting will be good, but the question of whether painting is something we are allowed to do has become a little less solemn.

A notebook can have a similar effect. This is an imagined, familiar notebook, with no distinguished owner and nothing written in it yet. Someone puts it in a bag and feels, briefly, that a thought encountered away from home could be worth keeping. The pages supply no evidence of literary ability. They do offer a place where an unremarkable sentence can exist without first defending its right to exist.

It is a peculiar authority to grant an object. Paper cannot assess a person’s seriousness, and a hinge has no opinion about vocation. Still, we sometimes accept an invitation from a thing more readily than encouragement from someone who loves us. The person may be generous, or mistaken. The thing merely accommodates the activity, which can feel like a more convincing form of belief.

Craig Mod’s essay on creative tools describes Robert Frank’s camera as a Leica IIIf, interpreting its portability as a kind of permission. An instrument has entered the story at the scale of a shoulder or a hand. What interests me is the smallness of the proposed intervention: something becomes easier to carry. A change in the burden of an activity may alter the size it occupies in the imagination.

A bulky arrangement can make an ordinary attempt feel like an occasion. Preparations gather around it, and with them the uncomfortable sense that the result will have to justify the preparations. Something portable leaves room for a less ceremonial relationship. A person can carry the possibility of making a picture without carrying an announcement about being a photographer. There is a certain mercy in that smaller public claim.

Of course, the object can also become a substitute for the attempt. Ownership offers an unusually tidy version of becoming: the future arrives complete, without the awkward work that would give it substance. This is part of the tenderness, and part of the trouble, of a new tool. The pleasure is real even when the promised work remains imaginary. A purchase cannot establish the talent it may help someone feel ready to test.

Van Gogh’s letter keeps another hand in view. He thanks Theo for the financial support that made materials and continued work possible. The box, considered by itself, might suggest a self-contained story of ingenuity. The letter makes that account harder to maintain. Its portability matters, but so does the money that allowed it to be acquired, and the person whose help entered the work before any color reached the page.

We like a tool to explain a beginning because a tool can be pictured. Support is less conveniently shaped. Someone else’s patience, or time freed from earning, does not sit neatly beside a palette in a photograph. These are possibilities the letter invites us to consider, rather than details it establishes about every maker. Permission can depend on arrangements that disappear when the story is reduced to the object in the hand.

In another letter from the same August, Van Gogh describes a perspective frame supported on stakes, with iron reinforcement. He also makes its usefulness depend on understanding perspective and practicing it. The qualification matters beside the delight of having an implement ready. A frame can assist a way of seeing that still has to be learned. Its physical certainty does not remove the uncertainty of the person looking through it.

There is something companionable about that limit. A tool capable of doing everything would leave its owner with an oddly diminished role. The imperfect arrangement leaves room for judgment, including judgment that is still being formed. It is possible to feel helped without being relieved of responsibility. The frame stands there, and the difficult business of seeing remains available to the person who wanted to see.

This complicates the suspicion that assistance somehow makes an attempt less legitimate. We can be strangely attached to difficulties that prove little beyond our willingness to endure them. A page that will not stay flat may become part of the ordeal of writing, as though the sentence needed an additional opponent. The irritation is real; its artistic necessity is less certain. Relief from it need not settle any grand question about the writer.

Mod’s other object is a book: a retrospective archive of Flipboard’s development, incorporating design material and engineering commit messages. He made two copies and presented the book after launch. Here, the making had already happened before the object gathered it into view. The book gives the reflection a different direction. A tool may change what seems permissible to preserve, as well as what seems possible to begin.

There is a quiet distinction between having done work and regarding that work as worthy of a place. A finished thing can make its own beginnings look disposable. False starts lose their usefulness, and the small decisions disappear behind the ease of the result. Giving those traces a form makes a claim for their continued company. An archive allows the labor to remain beside what the labor produced.

I keep returning to the watercolor box because its promise stays so close to an ordinary gesture. The lid opens; there is somewhere to mix a color. Around that modest provision, a person may gather hopes the object cannot fulfill and hesitations it cannot understand. The tool can make the next movement easier while leaving the larger question of who is entitled to make anything strangely untouched.

The tool has never asked who we think we are.

Further reading