New Ideas Hub
New Ideas Hub · Essays

Making a small living

The business before it has a shape

A name lets other people recognize an undertaking before its maker can be certain what, or how much, it will become.

A busy Edo street lined with shops whose curtains carry the same crest, Mount Fuji pale in the distance.
Utagawa Hiroshige, Suruga Street, ca. 1836 · The Met, public domain

The slippers in Craig Mod’s account already belong to an earlier version of the company. At a silkscreen facility, he finds them bearing a company name he changed the previous day. The discrepancy is small enough to smile at. Still, the lettering has acquired a steadiness that the undertaking itself does not yet possess. Even a pair of slippers can be more certain than its wearer.

A name usually seems to promise relief from this kind of uncertainty. Something previously difficult to explain can finally fit into a sentence, perhaps beside a person’s ordinary account of what they do. Friends can ask after it without making an elaborate gesture toward an unfinished thought. Yet their new ease of reference can make its owner uneasy. The name has traveled ahead of the explanation.

Before an undertaking is named, its unsettled parts can feel like possibilities. Afterward, the same unsettled parts may look like omissions: what it offers, whom it serves, whether anyone will pay. Nothing necessarily changed during the naming. A listener now has something definite to attach those questions to, and the person answering can hear the gaps more clearly. Uncertainty has become easier to point at.

Daniel Defoe encounters a less innocent naming problem in An Essay upon Projects. In his seventeenth-century English setting, the designation projector carries a suspicion of dubious schemes and deceptive promotion. He wants to discuss projects without simply accepting the disrepute attached to their authors. His distinction between honest execution and dishonest promotion belongs to that historical argument, rather than supplying an antique name for today’s founders. A category can prejudice a hearing before the particular proposal has been heard.

There is an uncomfortable generosity in recognizing this. Someone explaining an undertaking must contend with the memories that its description awakens in other people. An ambitious proposal can resemble a previous disappointment before its details become visible. Defoe’s defense leaves room for useful invention without making every bold promise respectable. The difficulty of being misunderstood does not establish that the person being misunderstood is right.

He complicates matters further with the wreck-recovery voyage of William Phips. In Defoe’s telling, failure would have exposed the undertaking to ridicule; success has largely spared it scrutiny. “But it had success, and who reflects upon the project?” The question interrupts the comfortable practice of letting an outcome certify the judgment that preceded it. It also makes the successful person’s earlier uncertainty harder to dismiss as a quaint episode on the road to vindication.

Once the ending is known, a beginning can seem to have been wearing a disguise. Every hesitation becomes evidence of perseverance, every change of direction a sign of responsiveness. A failed undertaking may leave exactly the same movements behind, available for a much less flattering interpretation. The name on the account has stayed put while the meaning of everything around it has changed. What once sounded like confidence can later be called presumption.

Benjamin Franklin’s printing press gives this uneasiness material weight. In his Autobiography, he recalls that the press and type were barely ready when George House brought in a customer. Their available cash had been spent, and the customer’s five shillings arrived with particular welcome. The scene contains both a business capable of taking an order and a business short of the money that would let it continue. Its existence and its security are separate questions.

Then Samuel Mickle appears at the door and asks whether Franklin is the young man who has opened the printing-house. On receiving his answer, Mickle predicts that the expensive undertaking will come to ruin. Franklin remembers being left melancholy by the conversation. Even allowing for the shaping hand of the later narrator, there is something recognizable about the encounter: another person can now identify the venture well enough to pronounce upon its future.

Mickle’s certainty is almost a service, though hardly a kind one. He supplies the conclusion that the beginning has failed to provide. A named undertaking invites such conclusions because it seems already to belong among things with settled descriptions. The maker may still be discovering what the work requires while the visitor has finished deciding what it means. Their conversation occurs at two different speeds.

The financial trouble Franklin recounts cannot be reduced to a discouraging visitor. His partner Meredith’s father supplied only half the money expected, and a merchant’s suit threatened the sale of the press and type. William Coleman and Robert Grace offered assistance; Franklin ultimately borrowed from both, settled the company’s debts, and advertised the partnership’s dissolution. The business that would continue in his own name emerged through help and an alteration of its obligations. A single name could not display everyone who had made its continuation possible.

That matters when reading an autobiography whose narrator knows what became of him. The remembered opening of the printing-house has already survived the danger it describes. Yet Franklin’s account keeps other people’s contributions in view, alongside the credit on which the enterprise depended. Its eventual clarity does not make the earlier arrangement self-sufficient. The story of a person becoming identifiable can also be the story of how much remains concealed behind that identity.

Perhaps this is part of the embarrassment of giving an undertaking a name. A short phrase has to stand in public for something that remains distributed across other people’s patience and work. It sounds singular while its maker is still negotiating dependencies. Pride in having begun can coexist with a reasonable discomfort about how complete the announcement sounds. Neither feeling needs to cancel the other.

There is also a quieter change in how time is felt. An unnamed undertaking can remain close to the day on which it is being considered; a named one can be remembered by someone who returns much later. Their question brings back an earlier intention, sometimes one its maker no longer recognizes. The name preserves a version of the future after the future has altered. An ordinary conversation can become an encounter with an abandoned expectation.

Being recognized can feel premature even when there has been real work. The undertaking has a place in conversation before its maker has a settled account of it. Some of the unease may come from hearing a provisional arrangement described as if it were a finished possession. There is no need for a fraudulent promise to create that mismatch. Ordinary grammar can sound more confident than the person speaking.

Now its uncertainty has an address.

Further reading