New Ideas Hub
New Ideas Hub · Essays

Becoming a beginner

The awkward first day

A hesitant pen, Keats’s dark passages, and Aristotle’s apprentices complicate the feeling that an unfamiliar beginning must be a mistaken one.

Young dancers wait and stretch in a rehearsal room while their teacher, leaning on a cane, watches one of them.
Edgar Degas, The Dance Class, 1874 · The Met, public domain

A pen held in the less accustomed hand makes a familiar word look doubtful. Oliver Burkeman uses writing with the nondominant hand as an analogy for unfamiliar change. In the picture his comparison calls up, the writer knows perfectly well what the word should be. The hand gives a less convincing account. Something understood has become something awkward to do.

There is a peculiar embarrassment in that gap. We can recognize the gesture, imagine its completion, even explain what would make it better, while remaining unable to perform it with any ease. Knowing what ease looks like may make the difficulty more conspicuous. A beginner who has never seen a good drawing has one fewer comparison to endure.

An imagined first evening in a drawing class brings the problem into a room. The other students have found places for their elbows; one seems already to know which pencil to choose. The newcomer spends an unreasonable amount of attention on the chair. Even the simple business of putting a bag down can seem to require a local education. Nothing disastrous has happened, but the evening has acquired the feeling of a mistake before much drawing has occurred.

That feeling deserves some room without being promoted immediately to the role of judge. The class might be unsuitable. It might also be the first occasion on which a person who likes drawings has had to occupy the less flattering position of someone learning to make them. From the chair, these possibilities need not announce themselves in different voices. The wish to leave could belong to either story, and the evening is still too young to supply an ending.

In a letter to John Hamilton Reynolds, Keats imagines the mind moving through a mansion. A bright chamber eventually opens onto darker passages as understanding becomes more complicated. The movement does not deliver the pleasing sequence in which each room is easier to see than the last. His phrase “we are in a mist” leaves the speaker inside it.

The darkness matters because it arrives within an account of awakening. Something has become visible that makes the whole scene harder to understand. Keats’s rooms offer company for a particular kind of bewilderment: the discovery that knowing more can make an earlier confidence unavailable. The view has widened, and the person looking has temporarily lost the neatness of the picture.

Elsewhere in the letters, writing to his brothers, Keats describes a person “capable of being in uncertainties, mysteries, doubts” in his account of negative capability. He is considering a literary capacity, not designing a test for whether a difficult choice is sound. Still, the phrase gives uncertainty a different place in a sentence. A person can be capable while the matter itself remains unsettled.

I find that grammatical possibility more interesting than the prospect of becoming comfortable with everything. There can be an interval between an experience and an adequate description of it. During that interval, discomfort is real, while its meaning remains incomplete. The drawing-class chair may feel wrong before its occupant knows whether the problem is the chair, the class, or the unfamiliar occupation of being a beginner. A first impression can have all its intensity without having acquired the last word.

Aristotle brings a less atmospheric object into the discussion: the work being made. In Book II of the Nicomachean Ethics, builders and harp players acquire their capacities through the corresponding activities. As he writes, “these we learn how to make by making.” The person who cannot yet do the thing well is, inconveniently, the person who must undertake some version of it.

There is no elegant arrangement here in which the ability arrives first and the embarrassing attempts can be omitted. Yet Aristotle also makes the difficulty less romantic. Practice can produce bad practitioners as well as good ones; the quality of the activity matters. Repetition does not acquire wisdom merely by accumulating occasions. A badly built thing remains a problem even if its maker found the experience character-building.

His account also separates an outwardly right action from acting with knowledge, deliberate preference, and a settled disposition. This distinction leaves room between performing something once and possessing the character associated with it. An action can be visible before the person performing it feels securely identified with it. The interval is awkward partly because observers may have a simpler story than the participant does.

In an imagined meeting, someone who has just spoken up may appear, for a moment, to be a person who speaks up in meetings. From inside, the contribution can still feel borrowed from a stranger, complete with a voice that sounded slightly too loud. The words have entered the conversation while their speaker remains privately unconvinced by the performance. There is something touching about an action arriving before its owner has decided it belongs to them.

Keats leaves understanding open; Aristotle keeps the quality of what is done in view. Together they make poor sponsors for a cheerful theory that discomfort proves progress. The uncertain person still has a world to notice, and the apprentice still has a piece of work to answer for. Neither the feeling nor the repetition can settle the whole account.

The distinction matters beyond books. A bad arrangement can be unfamiliar, and a familiar arrangement can be bad. Nothing about the uneasiness of a first encounter supplies a certificate of safety or goodness. Yet the opposite verdict can be premature too: the absence of ease may tell us less than the force of the feeling seems to promise.

The pen returns us to something smaller than a verdict on a life. A word is being attempted, and the attempt does not resemble the writer’s fluent version. That discrepancy is available to notice without requiring an immediate story about who the writer really is. Perhaps some beginnings feel so personal because they temporarily remove the ordinary evidence by which we recognize ourselves. The room contains us, but has none of our familiar arrangements.

The first day cannot remember us yet.

Further reading