New Ideas Hub
New Ideas Hub · Essays

Becoming a beginner

Before it looks like art

A crooked cup, a working drawing, and a porcelain jar complicate the distance between the art we love and the work we can make.

A large white porcelain jar, round and slightly uneven, against a plain grey ground.
Moon jar, Korea, Joseon dynasty, second half 18th century · The Met, public domain

A penciled cup can seem to lean even when the real cup stands perfectly straight. Its handle joins the body in an awkward place. Beside it, an open art book offers bowls that appear to contain air, weight, an entire afternoon. The two pages occupy the same table, and that small physical fact makes the comparison feel reasonable. One was made by someone learning to draw a cup. The other has already survived a great deal of selection.

The book may be the reason the drawing exists at all. Something in those pages made looking seem insufficient; there was a wish to take part. Yet the work that awakens the wish can also make its first expression feel embarrassing. The beginner has brought an affection into the room and discovered that it comes with standards. Loving a thing does not make the hand equal to it.

Joshua Reynolds describes a version of this difficulty in his sixth Discourse. The spectator sees the result of prolonged labor without having watched the gradual acquisition of skill. Unable to make anything comparable immediately, the spectator attributes the difference to a gift beyond ordinary reach. Reynolds locates part of the apparent gulf in the missing history. We are comparing what we can do now with a result whose preparation has disappeared from view.

There is a peculiar speed to admiration. A finished paragraph may move us before we have noticed how its sentences are arranged. A painted face seems to meet us all at once. Making asks us to encounter separately what appreciation allowed us to receive together. The feeling arrived in a moment; its means prove much slower to understand.

Reynolds does not respond by keeping students away from accomplished work. In his second Discourse, he proposes placing a student’s picture beside an admired example. He expects the comparison to hurt. But the ability to perceive a deficiency is, in his account, part of an advancing judgment. His student may see more clearly while feeling less pleased.

That is an uncomfortable possibility for anyone who wants improvement to announce itself as encouragement. A page can become harder to bear because the person reading it has become more exacting. This offers no guarantee that the page is improving along with its reader. Still, dissatisfaction need not have one meaning. There is a difference between finding everything hopeless and noticing, at last, precisely where the sentence goes slack.

Raphael’s study for the head of Saint Catherine survives on a sheet in the Ashmolean, where it may record a late alteration, perhaps after the full-size preparatory drawing, or an earlier solution revisited. That uncertainty matters when a master’s working page offers a tempting sort of company: here, apparently, is someone famous still deciding what to do. The sheet cannot securely illustrate an inept beginning, since a decision made within an acquired command of drawing belongs to a different situation from the effort to acquire that command. A loose line can carry a knowledge that a carefully repeated line has not yet found. Similar degrees of finish can conceal very different kinds of work.

Even when an expert’s sketch is rough, its comfort is less straightforward. The beginner may be seeking evidence that awkwardness is survivable, while the sketch shows an expert’s freedom to leave something unresolved. Both can matter without becoming interchangeable. There is no need for the master to have been helpless at this particular moment in order for a beginner’s helplessness to deserve patience. The drawing has its own business, beyond reassuring us.

A Korean white porcelain moon jar in the British Museum offers another kind of unevenness: its body was formed by joining two rounded halves, and bumps and cracks developed during firing. These are features of the finished vessel, rather than a record of someone’s first lesson, so the surface can bear marks of its making without those marks telling us how much the maker knew. We sometimes ask an irregular object to settle a much larger question: whether an awkward thing we have made is already beautiful. The resemblance may be consoling, but it cannot decide that question. An accomplished work retaining an irregularity and an inexperienced attempt share no automatic verdict. Beauty has not supplied a certificate for every wobble.

William Hazlitt offers a smaller, more particular pleasure in Table-Talk, in the essay On the Pleasure of Painting. Recalling an early attempt, he describes painting his father as he read Shaftesbury. A passage of skin, the color of a vein, could give him intense satisfaction when the paint produced the intended effect. He could imagine someday calling himself a painter. The pleasure did not wait for that future title to become secure.

The scale of this satisfaction interests me. A small area of paint had answered a particular intention. It did not have to answer for the whole picture, much less for the whole person making it. There can be room between pretending that everything is good and deciding that nothing counts. One convincing patch of skin occupies very little canvas, but it can occupy a considerable part of an afternoon.

Elsewhere in the same essay, Hazlitt describes the hand testing the eye, and the eye giving the hand further work. Observation is changed by the attempt to make it visible. This leaves less room for the idea of a complete inner picture merely awaiting competent delivery. The painter is also finding out what there is to see. An uncertain mark can expose a question that admiration had never required the observer to formulate.

The cup’s rim, for instance, may have seemed perfectly obvious before anyone tried to draw it. Now its curve is a problem with an actual shape. The disappointment has become local enough to be interesting, even if the drawing remains disappointing. This is a modest change, easily overshadowed by the wish to produce something worth showing. It gives the unsuccessful likeness a subject other than its maker’s inadequacy.

None of this promises that the distance will close. Some ambitions remain beyond the work we manage to make, and the work we love can retain its power to humble us. Yet an admired picture and a first attempt can occupy the same table without being rival claims to the same achievement. Between them sits someone whose pleasure has become more complicated. The open book still offers what first made drawing attractive; the page beside it now holds a troublesome, specific cup.

The cup has become harder to overlook.

Further reading