New Ideas Hub
New Ideas Hub · Essays

Where ideas live

What an unfinished thing leaves behind

A finished manuscript and a painted foot complicate the question of what survives when work fails to reach its hoped-for ending.

A painter sits at her easel with two pupils behind her; the canvas faces away from us.
Adélaïde Labille-Guiard, Self-Portrait with Two Pupils, 1785 · The Met, public domain

Craig Mod’s unpublished novel was finished. He describes years spent writing it, and credits the work with abilities that later entered his essays: shaping a scene, hearing a voice, handling dialogue. This is his own account of what carried over. The novel did not become a published book, but he came to recognize some of its work elsewhere.

A finished manuscript gives the question of wasted effort an awkward shape. There is something to point to, even if it has failed to enter the life imagined for it. The last page does not settle everything. A person can have completed the work and still feel stranded somewhere before the ending, waiting for the event that was supposed to make those years intelligible.

An unfinished project invites a similar reckoning, though it has stopped at a different threshold. We tend to ask about the hours in a tone we might use about money lent to someone who has disappeared. There ought to be a return, and preferably a recognizable one. A different way of seeing seems difficult to enter in the account beside three years and a stack of pages.

In October 1853, Gustave Flaubert wrote to Louise Colet about rereading Novembre, eleven years after writing it. He could still find good phrases and comparisons. He could also find the failure of the whole, which those pleasures did not repair. He meant to keep the work indefinitely, together with his earlier version of Éducation sentimentale, rather than offer it for publication.

There is something unusually exact about this response. Flaubert does not allow the good sentences to acquit the book, or the book to condemn every sentence. The judgment changes as he moves across the page. A comparison can still be alive inside a work he no longer believes in, without becoming evidence that the work deserves another chance in the world.

That seems a difficult distinction to keep when the work is our own. Affection for one passage can spread over the surrounding pages like favorable lighting. Disappointment can do the same in reverse, leaving even the parts that once seemed good looking faintly embarrassing. Either mood gives a convenient answer to the whole thing. A less convenient answer would have to remember precisely where the pleasure was.

The letter also leaves the labor where it happened. Flaubert does not establish that the intervening years have made Novembre worthwhile, or that keeping it will someday repay the trouble. He is rereading an earlier work and deciding what he thinks of it now. The manuscript has survived long enough to meet a reader who is both its author and no longer quite the person who wrote it.

Time spent on a project is often counted twice: once while it passes, and again when the result arrives. The second count can change the feeling of the first. A book published to indifference may make years that once felt absorbed and promising appear foolish. An eventual success may make the same frustrations seem necessary. Neither later verdict can quite reproduce what the hours contained before anyone knew.

There are real losses here, too ordinary to disappear into a lesson about creativity. The evenings could have held other work, or someone else’s company. Some abilities acquired with effort may never find another use. Even when something valuable survives, it need not equal what was given up. Calling a project useful can become another way of refusing to let it be over, as if it must keep earning its place in a life.

Balzac gives this uneasy arithmetic a visible object in The Hidden Masterpiece. When the visitors inspect Frenhofer’s painting, they see a confusion of accumulated paint, but also a beautifully realized bare foot. The foot belongs to a figure they cannot find in the rest of the canvas. Here, inside a fictional studio, the surviving achievement is small enough to be pointed at and insufficient to rescue the picture.

The foot is troublesome because it does not allow a clean verdict. It gives the visitors something to admire without giving Frenhofer the painting he believes he has made. Nor does their ability to see that fragment establish that they understand everything his work has meant to him. Admiration and failure occupy the same patch of canvas. Neither has the courtesy to disappear so the other can become the story.

The story ends with the report that Frenhofer has burned his canvases. Balzac does not leave the beautiful fragment safely available for a later exhibition. The painting’s fate puts pressure on the comforting notion that enough labor must eventually yield something we can keep. Fiction can make that pressure sharper than an encouraging example does: the foot was there, and its presence did not provide a way forward.

Flaubert’s decision to keep his pages and Balzac’s destroyed canvas refuse different simplifications. Keeping the work does not require calling it a success. Losing it does not prove that every part was worthless. Between those statements lies a less satisfying kind of account, with no final balance at the bottom. There may be discernment left over, or an unrepeatable pleasure, alongside a disappointment that has not become smaller for being understood.

The most elusive remainder may be a changed sense of what a piece of work requires. Someone might come away knowing the difference between a lively page and a convincing whole, a difference that was once only a phrase in a review. This is an imagined possibility, not a promised reward. Such knowledge could make the next attempt better. It could also make another attempt harder to begin, because the difficulty now has a recognizable size.

I find the demand for a verdict more wearing than the uncertainty. The project must have been worth it, or it must be regretted; its years seem unable to stay in the room without explaining themselves. Yet a piece of work can remain part of a life without furnishing that life with a lesson. It may leave a useful habit, or only a question whose wording has become more exact.

A manuscript kept after disappointment has an ordinary physical advantage over an explanation of why it was worthwhile. The explanation has to make sense; the pages only have to remain pages. They can contain a passage that still pleases their author, surrounded by work that does not. They can also be put away without a decision about whether the pleasure was enough.

The work may be over before its meaning is.

Further reading